Fixed vs. Variable Mortgages: Which is Right for You?

Tim Lyon • September 25, 2025

When arranging a mortgage, one of the first decisions you’ll need to make is whether to go with a fixed or variable rate. Both options have their own benefits and challenges, and understanding the differences will help you choose the one that fits your financial situation best.


In this post, we’ll break down the differences between fixed and variable mortgages, how they’re priced, the pros and cons of each, and what you should consider before making a decision.


What are Fixed and Variable Mortgages?

Fixed Rate Mortgage: Your interest rate stays the same for the entire mortgage term. That means your monthly payments won’t change, making budgeting more predictable.


Variable Rate Mortgage: Your interest rate changes during the term. There are two main types:

  • Variable Rate Mortgage (VRM): Your payment amount stays the same, but how much goes toward principal vs. interest changes as rates move.
  • Adjustable Rate Mortgage (ARM): Your payment amount itself changes when rates move.


How Do Fixed and Variable Mortgages Work?

Fixed
  • Your rate is set when you sign your mortgage contract.
  • Payments remain consistent, regardless of whether interest rates rise or fall.
  • Fixed rates are heavily influenced by the Canadian 5-year bond yield.
Variable
  • Your rate is tied to your lender’s prime rate, which follows the Bank of Canada’s overnight lending rate (reviewed 8 times a year).
  • Lenders usually offer a discount from prime, such as Prime – 0.4%.
  • You can often lock into a fixed rate at any time (though usually for a term equal to or longer than what’s left on your mortgage).


Penalties for Breaking Your Mortgage

Fixed
  • The greater of three months’ interest or the Interest Rate Differential (IRD). IRD can be very costly if rates have dropped since you signed.
Variable
  • Always three months’ interest — simpler and usually less expensive.


Pros and Cons

Fixed Rate Pros:
  • Predictable payments, easier budgeting
  • Protection if rates rise
  • Currently about 1% lower than variable, meaning you may qualify for more
Fixed Rate Cons:
  • More penalty risk if you break the mortgage early
  • You miss out if rates fall


Variable Rate Pros:
  • Benefit if rates decrease
  • Less penalty risk(3 months’ interest)
  • Option to lock into fixed at any time
Variable Rate Cons:
  • Payments (ARM) or interest portion (VRM) can rise if rates go up
  • Less predictable for budgeting
  • Lock-in rates may not always be the best available



Quick Summary

• Fixed mortgages = stable, predictable, tied to bond yields, but more penalty risk.
Variable mortgages = tied to Bank of Canada, potential savings, lower penalty risk, but less predictable.
VRM vs. ARM = VRM keeps payments steady while ARM adjusts payments with rates.


Next Steps

Choosing between fixed and variable depends on your risk tolerance, financial goals, and comfort with rate changes. If you’re unsure which option is right for you, let’s talk about your situation and find the best fit.

Need help with your mortgage? Book a consultation or call 778-988-8409.


Mortgage Term Glossary

Adjustable Rate Mortgage (ARM): A variable mortgage where payments increase or decrease as rates change.
Amortization:
The total length of time it will take to pay off your mortgage completely (typically 25–30 years in Canada).
Bond Yield:
The return investors get from government bonds. Used as a benchmark for fixed mortgage rates.
Down Payment:
The upfront amount you pay toward the purchase price of a home, expressed as a percentage of the total price.
Equity:
The difference between what your home is worth and what you owe on your mortgage.
Fixed Rate:
An interest rate that stays the same for the entire mortgage term.
Interest Rate Differential (IRD):
A penalty calculation for breaking a fixed mortgage when current rates are lower than your original rate.
Lock-In:
The option to switch from a variable mortgage to a fixed mortgage during your term.
Mortgage Term:
The length of your mortgage contract with your lender (typically 1–5 years), after which you need to renew.
Prime Rate:
The interest rate banks use as a baseline for loans, influenced by the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate.
Variable Rate Mortgage (VRM):
A variable mortgage where payments stay the same, but the principal vs. interest split changes with rate moves.
Variable Rate:
An interest rate that changes during your mortgage term based on lender prime rates.

Tim Lyon

Mortgage Consultant

By Tim Lyon October 28, 2025
If you're buying a home with less than 20% down, you'll need something called an insured mortgage. Many borrowers find this confusing at first, especially since it doesn’t refer to insurance for you, the borrower. That’s why I have put together this straightforward breakdown so you understand what insured mortgages are, why they exist, and how they affect your purchase. What Is an Insured Mortgage? A mortgage must be insured when a borrower makes a down payment of less than 20% on a home purchase. The insurance protects the lender (not the borrower) in case the borrower defaults. The insurance is guaranteed by the federal government. So, why do we have this program? It allows borrowers to buy homes with smaller down payments and higher loan-to-value (LTV) ratios. Higher loan-to-value mortgages are inherently more risky because there is not much cushion if the housing market starts to decline. For example, if someone buys a $500,000 home with only 5% down ($25,000), they’ll need a $475,000 mortgage—this is a 95% LTV . If the market drops and the home’s value falls to $470,000, the mortgage would still be $475,000. If the borrower stopped making payments, the lender could lose money after selling the home and paying costs. That kind of loss, multiplied across thousands of borrowers, could threaten the stability of the entire banking system (as we saw in the U.S. in 2008). The mortgage insurance system is designed to prevent that scenario by spreading risk and keeping lenders protected. How Does the Insurance Work? You, the borrower, pay the insurance premium. It's typically added directly to your mortgage balance rather than paid upfront. The cost depends on your down payment size and amortization. Example: Purchase price: $500,000 Down payment: $25,000 (5%) Mortgage amount: $475,000 Insurance premium: 4.2% = $19,950 Total new mortgage: $494,950 The insurance does add cost, but insured mortgages usually offer slightly lower interest rates because the lender's risk is minimal. The rate savings don't fully offset the premium, but they help. The Insurer’s Role For insured mortgages, the insurer’s approval is the most important part of the process. If the insurer won’t approve the file, no lender can. Once the insurer signs off, we can typically find a lender to fund the loan. Canada has three mortgage insurers: CMHC (public) Sagen (private) Canada Guaranty (private) All of the insurers are backed by government guarantees and have to follow similar rules, but each has a few unique programs. Lenders usually choose the insurer, though I sometimes work with them to send a file to a specific insurer if it benefits the borrower. Qualification Rules Because insured mortgages are government-backed, the rules are strict: Debt ratios: 39% of your income can go toward your stress-tested mortgage payment, property taxes, heat, and half of condo fees 44% of your income can go toward the above plus your other debts Down payment: 5% on the first $500,000, 10% on the remainder Maximum purchase price: $1.5 million Amortization: Maximum of 25 years for most buyers; up to 30 years for first-time buyers who qualify under the new federal program Unlike with an uninsured mortgage, where lenders may have some flexibility if your income ratios are slightly above the limits, there is no discretion on an insured mortgage. If your ratios exceed the limits even a little bit, the insurer will decline the application. The Approval Process The process is similar to an uninsured mortgage, with one extra step: We submit your mortgage application to the lender of choice They do their initial review If that looks good, they package it up and send it to the insurer Once the insurer has reviewed and approved it, the file comes back to the lender for final review and approval Common Misunderstandings About Insured Mortgages Many borrowers are surprised to learn the following facts about insured mortgages: You do not need to be a first-time homebuyer to buy with less than 20% down You cannot buy an investment property with less than 20% down You can buy a second home with less than 20% down You cannot refinance an insured mortgage and keep the insurance. If you have an insured mortgage and do refinance, you will lose the insurance. This mostly affects the lender, but it also moves you to uninsured rates. Why Choose an Insured Mortgage? Given the cost and restrictions, why would anyone choose an insured mortgage? The main reason is accessibility . It allows you to buy a home without saving a full 20% down payment, which is increasingly difficult with high home prices and living costs. It can also be a strategic choice. Some buyers prefer to keep more of their savings invested or diversified instead of tying everything up in a down payment. If your investments are earning more than your mortgage costs, keeping that money invested might make financial sense. Real-World Example Let's say you're buying a $600,000 home. Here's how the costs compare between the minimum down payment for an insured mortgage and the minimum down payment for an uninsured mortgage:
By Tim Lyon October 20, 2025
The part of mortgage approval nobody likes but everyone needs